[Cankor] Report #245
cankor at cankor.ca
cankor at cankor.ca
Sun Apr 16 14:05:58 CDT 2006
Dear subscriber,
Welcome to issue #245 of the CanKor Report.
In this week's QUIDNUNC, Charles Burton responds to the question: Has the
Six-Party Talks process run its course?
Aidan Foster-Carter and Jake Buhler offer their take on the question: What
is the DPRK's most urgent need?
Jeff Nankivell and Charles Burton wonder: How many people in North Korea
have unfettered access to information about the world outside the DPRK?
Please do not hesitate to send to editor at CanKor.ca your replies or
additional questions that may stump or amuse our many expert subscribers and
contributors.
The CanKor team.
For articles not original to CanKor, direct links are available in the
Contents section, should you wish to consult the originals on the internet.
If the links no longer function, you may refer to the full text articles
appended to the issue.
For back issues, archives and other content, please visit our website:
http://www.cankor.ca
*************************************************
CANADA-KOREA ELECTRONIC INFORMATION SERVICE
CanKor # 245
Friday, 14 April 2006
*************************************************
Although both US and DPRK chief delegates to Six Party Talks attend a
security conference in Tokyo, no bilateral contact is made between them, as
many were hoping. DPRK chief negotiator Kim Gye Gwan calls on the USA to
unfreeze financial assets in order to allow the resumption of the talks, but
expresses no urgency. In the meantime, the DPRK would continue to "make more
deterrent".
An eight-member bipartisan and bicameral US congressional aide delegation
visits the Kaesong Industrial Complex to research the nature of the economic
relationship between the two Koreas. At stake are the ROK's wish to join the
Visa Waiver Program, and the US-Korea free trade agreement.
The fourth session of the 11th Supreme People's Assembly (SPA) takes place
in Pyongyang on 11 April. The annual meeting reviews the Cabinet's work, the
status of the economy, plans for the coming year, and the most significant
issues of interest to DPRK leaders. Although the urgent need to "build a
nationwide information network and develop programming technology rapidly"
figures high on the agenda this year, agriculture, coal and metals are seen
as the most important tasks.
The DPRK appears on the verge of announcing dramatic new reforms dealing
with real estate, such as leasing out state-owned mountains to individuals
on a long-term basis, imposing taxes on state-owned land used by factories
and businesses, and leasing out plots of collective farms to families.
The Research Institute for the North Korean Society, published by Good
Friends: Centre for Peace, Human Rights and Refugees reports that the DPRK
National Police has posted a decree on severe punishments to be meted out
for slashing electric power or communication lines and illegal drug
transactions. This week's FOCUS on crime and punishment in the DPRK
reproduces an English translation of the decree, and reports on incidents
that appear to be signs of its implementation.
*************************************************
Contents:
1. DPRK THREATENS TO BOOST NUCLEAR ARSENAL
http://today.reuters.com/news/articlenews.aspx?type=topNews&storyid=2006-04-13T092228Z_01_SEO330018_RTRUKOC_0_US-KOREA-NORTH.xml
2. US CONGRESSIONAL AIDES VISIT KAESONG INDUSTRIAL COMPLEX
http://joongangdaily.joins.com/200603/20/200603202215559909900090209021.html
3. DPRK WEIGHING THE BENEFITS OF THE NUCLEAR CARD
http://www.stratfor.com/products/premium/login.php
4. DPRK TO ANNOUNCE REAL ESTATE REFORMS
http://english.donga.com/srv/service.php3?bicode=060000&biid=2006041377768
FOCUS: Crime and punishment in the DPRK
5. DPRK POSTS DECREE WITH SEVERE PUNISHMENTS
http://www.goodfriends.or.kr/eng/eng.html
6. DECREE ON SLASHING POWER LINES, DRUG TRANSACTIONS
http://www.goodfriends.or.kr/eng/eng.html
7. EXPULSION OF 15 DRUG DEALERS' FAMILIES IN HOERYONG
http://www.goodfriends.or.kr/eng/eng.html
8. PUBLIC EXECUTION OF DRUG DEALERS AT CHONGJIN
http://www.goodfriends.or.kr/eng/eng.html
9. TEENAGER EXECUTED FOR IMITATING ROK FILM GANGSTER
http://www.goodfriends.or.kr/eng/eng.html
QUIDNUNC: Readers ask and respond to common and uncommon questions
THIS WEEK: 1. Has the Six-Party Talks process run its course?
2. What is the DPRK's most urgent need?
*************************************************
1. DPRK THREATENS TO BOOST NUCLEAR ARSENAL
Reuters, 13 April 2006
North Korea said on Thursday it might boost its nuclear deterrent if
six-country talks on ending its atomic programs remained deadlocked, but
said it would return if Washington met a demand to unfreeze it assets.
Pyongyang's top envoy to the stalled negotiations told a news conference in
Tokyo the United States must lift what the North considers to be financial
sanctions against it.
"I told them the minute we have the funds or I have the funds in my hand I
will be at the talks. But if they continue to come with pressure and
sanctions, we will respond with extremely strong measures," envoy Kim
Kye-gwan said. "There is nothing wrong with delaying the resumption of the
six-party talks. In the meantime we can make more deterrent. If the United
States doesn't like that, they should create the condition for us to go back
to the talks."
In an official media report on Thursday, North Korea reiterated it has been
building a nuclear deterrent to counter what it views as Washington's
hostile policy toward it. Washington has clamped down on a Macau-based bank
it suspects of assisting Pyongyang in illicit financial activities,
including money laundering. Kim has been in Tokyo, where he attended a
security symposium along with most of the other chief delegates to the
six-party talks, including US envoy Christopher Hill. At the airport before
departing, Kim said it was up to the United States to seek bilateral
discussions. "I always have patience," he said.
An analyst in Seoul said Kim's comments might indicate Pyongyang was fishing
for a compromise, where the United States could say not all of the North's
accounts frozen at the Macau bank were used for illicit activity and then
free up some funds.
"Seoul's preference is for the US to find some gesture that will help North
Korea save face. China's position is not all that different," said Kim
Sung-han, head of North American studies at the Institute of Foreign Affairs
and National Security.
Analysts have said a meeting between the US and Chinese presidents next week
in the United States could also increase the pressure on North Korea to
return to talks. Beijing is urging flexibility on the financial crackdown.
Tokyo says Pyongyang must appreciate that unless the atomic issue and a
separate standoff with Japan over abductees is resolved the North's already
weak economic position would deteriorate further.
Hill, currently in South Korea, said Pyongyang was boycotting the
discussions, but urged patience for the stalled process. Washington says the
financial issue is separate from the nuclear talks and has urged Pyongyang
to return to the talks. Hill said the amount of the frozen Macau funds was
about $20 million, equal to approximately one week's worth of energy aid
proposed by South Korea for the North in return for scrapping its nuclear
programs.
"The DPRK needs to understand that as long as it is going to be producing
nuclear weapons, we are going to be having a real close look at its
finances," Hill said, referring to the North's official name, the Democratic
People's Republic of Korea. Hill, who was in Tokyo until Wednesday, had no
substantive discussions with Kim in the Japanese capital, dimming prospects
for renewed progress in the nuclear talks. Hill said he was ready to meet
Kim face-to-face within the six-party format. The last round of the talks
among the two Koreas, China, Japan, Russia and the United States was held in
November.
*************************************************
2. US CONGRESSIONAL AIDES VISIT KAESONG INDUSTRIAL COMPLEX
Joong Ang Ilbo, 12 April 2006
An eight-member US congressional aide delegation visited an inter-Korean
industrial complex on Tuesday to look at the nature of the economic
relationship between the two Koreas, the South Korean Embassy here said
Wednesday. The delegation, made up of bipartisan, bicameral staff members,
has been in Seoul from Sunday to meet with South Korean government,
parliamentary and economic organization officials to discuss political and
trade issues, the embassy said.
"The two key issues that have been raised during the staff delegation's
extensive meetings include South Korea's efforts to join the Visa Waiver
Program, as well as the US-Korea free trade agreement (FTA)," it said.
The Kaesong industrial complex, located just north of the heavily fortified
Korean border, is a pilot project that combines the capital of South Korean
companies with the cheap labor force of North Korea to manufacture export
items at competitive prices. The venture has raised some questions in the
United States about the use of sensitive items and technology that are on
Washington's export control list, and more broadly, if such economic
cooperation is in line with international efforts to press North Korea to
give up its nuclear weapons.
It is now viewed in the context of the FTA negotiations, whether products
out of Kaesong can be considered goods produced by South Korea and also if
North Korean workers are being paid and treated according to international
standards.
"According to sources close to the delegation, the trip to the Kaesong
industrial complex was pivotal because members of Congress need to
understand the nature of the economic relationship between the two Koreas,
particularly in light of the launching of negotiations for a US-South Korea
free trade agreement," the embassy said. Doug Anderson, a staff member of
the House International Relations Committee, visited Kaesong last month.
*************************************************
3. DPRK WEIGHING THE BENEFITS OF THE NUCLEAR CARD
Stratfor, 13 April 2006
SUMMARY
North Korea's parliament, the Supreme People's Assembly (SPA), met April 11
to discuss government and economic performance for the past year and the
coming year, and to plan out the government's priorities. Though the SPA is
often considered a rubber-stamp parliament, its discussions in recent years
have offered insight into the shape of upcoming North Korean policies. In
the plans for 2006, the emphasis is again on agriculture, but there also is
a clear impetus to accelerate international economic interactions -- and
these could indicate Pyongyang's further intentions regarding the ongoing
nuclear crisis.
ANALYSIS
The fourth session of the 11th Supreme People's Assembly (SPA) of North
Korea met in Pyongyang on April 11 to review the Cabinet's work and the
status of the economy, as well as to discuss plans for 2006 and the role of
technology in North Korea's development. The annual meetings of the
oft-described "rubber-stamp" parliament may not set policies, but they do
provide insight into the most significant issues of interest to North
Korea's leaders.
The underlying theme of the 2006 session was "stepping up the development of
science and technology to give strong impetus to the building of a great
prosperous powerful nation." While this sounds rather grandiose, it is no
coincidence that much of leader Kim Jong Il's January visit to China focused
on technology as the underpinning of economic development, from the
traditional high-tech industries all the way down to core sectors such as
agriculture.
Two key high-tech initiatives were laid out in the SPA session. First was
the "urgent [need] to build a nationwide information network and develop
programming technology rapidly" in order to turn North Korea "into a power
in software development." Pyongyang may intend to have foreign firms
outsource to North Korea, as international animation studios already do.
Second was the call for the establishment of science and technology hubs
that bring together scientists for research, study and development of new
ideas and technologies. These technology incubators will also try to draw on
cooperation with foreign scientists.
As with many developing nations, and particularly with socialist ones,
technology is seen as the path toward greatness. But it also is seen as a
pragmatic necessity to leap over the various stages of development in order
to catch up with the rest of the world.
Although technology got top billing as a theme, the most important tasks
laid out related to agriculture, coal and metals. North Korea has seen five
consecutive years of increased grain output following a terrible year in
2000, and at the end of 2005 negotiated an end to grain donations from the
World Food Program in favour of assistance in growing its own foods. The
larger crop yields were still insufficient, but the push on agriculture,
which was the main focus of the April 2005 SPA session, apparently has begun
to pay off. In the future, North Korea intends to increase research and
development into bioengineering better crops and into additional fertilizer
production utilizing coal gasification for the feedstock.
Coal takes second billing, but only slightly so. North Korean coal
production continues to climb, and Pyongyang not only uses it at home for
energy but also exports it to China. Although coal remains a primary source
of energy, Pyongyang also continues to expand the development and use of
hydropower. The government also has recognized the critical state of the
energy infrastructure and called for an increased focus on energy
management, the development of renewable energy sources (such as wind and
biomass) and energy-efficient devices, and the use of energy-saving
practices. Given the huge increase in international oil prices, these are
even more critical issues for North Korea than perhaps for its neighbours.
Interestingly, Pyongyang also laid out the need to develop its oil
exploration and production technology, perhaps with an eye on potential
resources in the West Sea.
Metal is the final piece of the economic trinity. Pyongyang is looking to
increase metal production, particularly steel, and divert that production to
critical areas such as improving the energy infrastructure and the rail
infrastructure. Both are in a particularly poor state (as the 2004 Ryongchon
blast showed), though Pyongyang has over the past few years increased
attention to rail as part of a regional push to connect South Korea by
railroad to Russia and China (and eventually on to Europe), all via North
Korea. In addition, rail remains the most effective way of moving coal and
other energy resources, as well as grain, through the country.
As Pyongyang lays out its 2006 plans, it sees the six-party nuclear talks
languishing, and wonders if they are even necessary anymore. There is a
clear impasse, and Pyongyang increasingly doubts whether Washington is
either willing to make a deal or capable of enforcing any deal that might be
made. Furthermore, South Korea continues to work economically with the
North, and once again, international economic cooperation plays a prominent
role in the SPA plans for the coming year. As such, the need for a
settlement with Washington appears to be waning.
The initial intent of the 2003 nuclear crisis, after all, was to force a
peace settlement with the United States, thus breaking the international
taboo on doing business with North Korea and carefully managing the opening
of special economic zones to take advantage of cheap North Korean labour --
all while bringing in cash and technology to North Korea to be redistributed
throughout the rest of the country by the central government. If Seoul
continues to work with North Korea in Kaesong and elsewhere, and Pyongyang
wants to retain a close hold over the pace and scope of economic
experimentation, having Seoul on its side even without a peace accord with
Washington is not a bad position.
For Pyongyang, however, there is a question of time. While it sees little
potential progress from Washington any time soon (and is thus refraining
from taking the necessary steps to satisfy Washington and restart the
six-party talks), Pyongyang also sees its rapprochement with South Korea
facing a troubling time as the South's December 2007 presidential election
approaches. Pyongyang foresees the likely return of a more conservative
government in Seoul, one not nearly as open to sharing money and technology
with the North, making 2006 and the first half of 2007 critical years for
North Korean economic developments. A deal with Washington would reduce the
risk of a change in the South Korean government, but it also would be of
questionable value until perhaps after the 2006 US congressional
elections -- but those are well beyond the spring deadline Washington has
laid out for the potential continuation of six-party talks.
The ball is now clearly in North Korea's court. The ability to restart the
six-party talks rests in Pyongyang's willingness, or lack thereof, to
identify its nuclear sites for future dismantling. Pyongyang could easily
accede, submit the sites and restart negotiations. But if it deems it
unlikely that Washington will go so far as to sign a peace accord to replace
the armistice or finally establish formal diplomatic relations, Pyongyang
might look at the cost-vs.-benefit of continued drawn-out talks over an
artificially created crisis and decide simply to focus on its economic ties
with Seoul and a few other select states. It could then let the nuclear
question remain unresolved until there is another opportunity -- or need --
to play the nuke card.
*************************************************
4. DPRK TO ANNOUNCE REAL ESTATE REFORMS
Donga Ilbo, 13 APRIL 2006
North Korea seems to be preparing for new economic reforms centered on real
estate reform. According to sources knowledgeable to North Korea, measures
that North Korea is about to take contain some dramatic changes, including
leasing out state-owned mountains to individuals on a long-term basis, and
imposing taxes on state-owned land which is used by factories and
businesses. Other measures include granting rights to develop and operate
roads on a long-term basis to local and foreign businesses as well as
individuals, and recognizing ownership of new apartments constructed and
sold by businesses or individuals.
In addition, North Korea is said to be considering a plan to lease out plots
of collective farms to families. The review for the plan was completed early
last year, but it has been put on the shelf for a year due to the political
situation at home and abroad. Sources say that the new measures will be
implemented by the order of the cabinet starting this April. One source said
on yesterday, "For five days starting April 4, the North Korean authorities
held working-level meetings that gathered together production unit
supervisors in major cities around the country and taught them the new real
estate policies."
According to the source, on the first day of the meeting, the participants
were informed that taxes would be imposed on land used by factories and
businesses depending on the size of land occupied. Moreover, it has been
recently confirmed that a new department called the "real estate development
department" was established inside each people's committee, which is the
North Korean equivalent of a local government. What it means is that real
estate, a relatively new concept for North Koreans, has been first
introduced into North Korean governmental agencies.
Yang Mun-soo, a professor at the University of North Korean Studies said,
"In the past also, North Korea had to inevitably lease out state-owned
stores and shops to individuals for national financing. The reform measures
that North Korea is about to embark on seem to be in line with that." He
added, "However, what is notable is that the subjects of lease-out have been
expanded to state-owned land."
North Korea demonstrated its will to restore the socialist system when it
reinstated the rationing system last October. However, there is an analysis
that since the National Defense Committee Chairman Kim Jong Il made a visit
to China last July, North Korea has taken a turn toward reforms and opening
up once again. In particular, this round of reform measures is expected to
further inspire capitalist ways of thinking into North Korean residents, as
the Economic Management Improvement Measure announced on July 1, 2002, did.
Meanwhile, the Financial Times reported on April 9, "North Korea will embark
on a new round of economic reform measures immediately after the birthday of
its late leader Kim Il-sung (April 15)." It said, "The new measures will
start quietly."
Kevin Shepherd, a researcher at the Institute for Far Eastern Studies
affiliated to the Kyungnam University, told the Financial Times,
"Considering the recent reports from North Korean state-owned media outlets,
North Korea seems to be preparing to bring about another round of changes to
the North Korean economy." In particular, he brought to the attention the
fact that the North Korean state-owned media outlets recently mentioned ways
to improve labor. According to him, the North Korean state-owned media
outlets said, it is more desirable for wages to be given to workers on a
daily or a weekly basis, rather than on a monthly basis. The Financial Times
also reported that for the first time in 10 years, "the national labor
planning meeting" was held, and North Korean Prime Minister Pak Pong Ju and
a large number of economic officials participated in the meeting.
The Financial Times forecasted that if North Korea takes on additional
economic reforms, legal changes would take place so that more authority will
be given to supervisors of businesses, and businesses and production units
can attract foreign capital more actively. The Financial Times added, "The
financial sanctions of the United States against North Korea also seem to
have motivated North Korea into taking on economic reforms. Those who have
visited North Korea recently say that it is more difficult than before to
gain hold of foreign currencies in North Korea."
*************************************************
FOCUS: Crime and punishment in DPRK
*************************************************
5. DPRK POSTS DECREE WITH SEVERE PUNISHMENTS
North Korea Today, Research Institute for the North Korean Society, 13th
Issue, 20 March 2006
The State Department of the US government has published the 'Report on the
Strategies to Control the Illegal Substances' on the March 1st, 2006.
Although there is a disclaimer that more precise evidences are needed, but
the United States government criticised that the enough evidences show the
involvement of the North Korean government. The North Korean government on
the March 7th, 2006 have condemned that this report is part of the coercive
US policy, to conspire defamation and pressure against North Korea. In
addition, the ship crew of the 'Bongsooho' was held in prison for accusation
on smuggling heroin to Australia in 2003. The entire crew were found
innocent from the trial that went on for two years and ten months, thus,
this has put a break on the coercive US policy towards North Korea from
laying allegations on counterfeiting notes to drug issues.
Meanwhile, the North Korean government has released a decree on the March
1st, 2006 before the US State Department released the annual report on the
Strategies to Control the Illegal Substances'. The decree outlines anyone
who gets involved in slashing electrical lines or telecommunication lines or
any involvement in producing, dealing with drugs will be sentenced with
severe punishments. This is an indirect acknowledgement from the North
Korean Government that the drug is being a serious social problem despite
the determination of the government.
The confrontation of the US versus North Korea is apparent with series of
issues such as human rights violation, counterfeiting on notes and drugs
while the Six Party Talks seem to be in a slump. The reconciliation between
the US and the North Korea is still seemed have lost its way in the midst of
the mistrust between the two states.
*************************************************
6. DECREE ON SLASHING POWER LINES, DRUG TRANSACTIONS
National Police Agency of DPRK, 1 March 2006
Slashing electric power or communication lines and illegal drug transactions
are anti-state crimes impeding our economic development and national defence
that paralyzes our people's revolutionary consciousness and demolishing our
whole-hearted solidarity on political ideology of the leaders of the
revolution.
National Police Agency, therefore, decrees as follow on behalf of the
Government of Democratic People's Republic of Korea.
1. Do not Slash nor Destroy Electric Power or Tele-Communication Lines.
-- Do not commit any acts of cutting or stealing the power and communication
lines.
-- Do not get involved in any acts of buying and selling of copper,
especially to other countries.
-- Institutions, businesses, organizations, and citizen are forbidden to use
copper to manufacture various products to sell.
-- Electrical and telecommunication workers shall not violate the
management, supervision and guarding regulation regarding the electrical and
telecommunication equipments.
2. Illegal Transactions of Drugs Ought Not to be Engaged.
-- Do not sell, buy nor use drugs illegally.
-- Do not cultivate raw materials nor manufacture drugs illegally.
-- Institutions, workplaces and organisations should not illegally produce
nor export drug.
-- Institutions, workplaces and organisations should not offend the
storages, handlings and usage order of drugs.
3. Watch out for any illegal activities on slashing electric and
telecommunication lines or drug transactions, and report it to the police
authorities immediately.
-- Do not delay nor hinder from informing, nor take revenge on informers.
4. Those who have engaged in slashing electric and telecommunication lines
and illegal drug transactions should voluntarily surrender themselves to the
police.
-- Those who surrender within 10 days after this decree shall be generously
forgiven.
5. Offenders of this decree shall be sentenced to death regardless of their
status, services and achievements.
-- Anyone who organised or initiated activities that offend this decree
shall be sentenced to heavy penalty up to death, and their family shall be
expelled.
-- Anyone who conspire or support the activities that offend shall also be
sentenced to heavy penalty.
-- Supervisors and Guardians of the institutions, workplaces and
organisations that the offender of this decree is belonging to shall take
due responsibilities for the act committed.
-- Transportations, equipments, money and materials used for the activities
offending this decree shall be confiscated in all circumstances irrespective
of their positions.
-- Anyone who hinders or resist execution of this decree shall be arrest in
the act.
6. This decree shall be adopted in all institutions, workplaces,
organizations (including military and special institutions) and people, in
the lawful territory of the Democratic People's Republic of Korea.
*************************************************
7. EXPULSION OF 15 DRUG DEALERS' FAMILIES IN HOERYONG
North Korea Today, Research Institute for the North Korean Society, 14th
Issue, 20 March 2006
The residents of Hoeryung had a general assembly at the Tangang Machenary
Factory on the March 14, 2006. The agenda was on the expulsion of the
individuals and their families who dealt (bought, used or sold) with drug
called 'er-reum (a kind of amphatamine -- also known as "speed"). As a
result from the general assembly, 15 households including the individuals
and family who dealt with drugs and gambling were expelled from the city.
Residents are living in insecurity and fear unknowing who will be arrested
and expelled the next.
*************************************************
8. PUBLIC EXECUTION OF DRUG DEALERS AT CHONGJIN
North Korea Today, Research Institute for the North Korean Society, 14th
Issue, 20 March 2006
On March 30, 2006, there was a public execution for two people on the bank
of the Soo-sung-chun creek near Soonam District Marketplace. According to
the decree that was posted on March 1, 2006 about the offenders slashing
electrical and tele-communication lines, any one who deal drugs will be laid
heavy punishment regardless of their position, achievements and statues. It
then specifically mentions the punishment is up to death penalty and the
rest of the family will be expelled from the town. The decree also mentions
those who come forward and self-report their offence to the authority before
the March 10, 2006 will be graciously forgiven.
The two men who had public execution, were arrested before the posting of
the decree and the public execution was held as a model case. The one of the
offenders was guilty of drug smuggling and another was found guilty of
showing forbidden films.
*************************************************
9. TEENAGER EXECUTED FOR IMITATING ROK FILM GANGSTER
North Korea Today, Research Institute for the North Korean Society, 14th
Issue, 20 March 2006
In early March, Song, a 6th grade high school student in Chongjin city, was
executed by shooting. After seeing a South Korean movie about mobsters, Song
formed an organization with other secondary grade students from Pohang and
Soonam regions. They would gather, call in other female students and drink
and watch movies.
They killed traitors who leaked their secrets out or those who have
abandoned their group. The followers of Song who tattooed themselves 'Song's
Special Guard' on their wrist were also apprehended. Song, found guilty on
charges of murder and acts of violence, received the maximum penalty of
death and other teenagers were sent to the Hoeryung Junguri Re-Education
Centre.
Their behaviour is considered more than simple acts of imitation by
teenagers, were deemed anti-regime as they imitated 'The Great Leader's
Special Guards' and severe punishments were given accordingly.
*************************************************
QUIDNUNC
In this section of CanKor, we invite readers to send questions, answers, or
responses. Answers should be under 150 words and may be edited for space.
*************************************************
HAS THE SIX-PARTY TALKS PROCESS RUN ITS COURSE?
*************************************************
The Six Party Talks are intended to lead to the DPRK regime providing
verifiable evidence that it poses no nuclear threat to the USA, China,
Russia, Japan and the ROK. Once it is ensured that the DPRK has no capacity
to explode a nuclear bomb, presumably the next step would be to induce the
DPRK to come into compliance with other international norms. The domestic
institutional changes necessary to come into compliance would threaten the
existing political status quo in North Korea. So the DPRK does not find it
in its interest to initiate such a process by ceasing to project a
perception that it poses a nuclear threat to neighbouring countries. So the
Talks make no substantive progress. Mostly they seem to wile away the months
and years in negotiations about the process. In the long term this could end
up badly.
Charles Burton, Professor, Brock University, St. Catherines, Ontario, Canada
*************************************************
WHAT IS THE DPRK'S MOST URGENT NEED?
*************************************************
The DPRK's most urgent need is a change of government.
Aidan Foster-Carter, Honorary Senior Research Fellow in Sociology & Modern
Korea, Leeds University, UK
*************************************************
As the birthday of Kim Il Sung nears, it seems right to ask what the
Democratic Republic of Korea's greatest need might be. As someone from a
wealthy country, and as a Canadian whose Government is cool to the DPR of
Korea, perhaps the question could be reversed. I would like to ask what
Canada's greatest needs are regarding that sovereign state. One question
might be what Canada could do to reduce tension in the Korean Peninsula. Our
posture at present is to view the DPRK as a possible threat. We take our
cues from the Americans, and as long as we do, we will see the DPRK as an
adversarial nation. While our influence in that region is small at best,
Canada could use its reasonably good reputation to leverage changes more
widely. Often, a warm gesture invites a warm response. What keeps us from
giving unconditional gestures is the human rights issue. We hang it like a
curtain to block out the sun.
Before our Government can dialogue with the Government of the DPRK on
substantive issues, we must find low-level ways to communicate with them.
Having worked with academics in Pyongyang for 3 months, I was impressed at
the openness with which I was able to work with them. I walked about the
entire city without restriction. I was received kindly by academic
institutions. Canada has an opportunity to engage Korean academics by
offering them opportunities to study in Canadian universities. Methods to
improve Korea's food security issue is a priority. Korea needs to develop
ways to multiply its imported food products through secondary manufacturing.
We can send wheat to the DPRK, but the multiplier effects are not present.
Wheat can be integrated and transformed into other forms of food. Let's work
at exchanges to make it happen. With grants from the Canadian International
Development Agency and IDRC, such exchanges and expertise could be
developed. In the meantime, while Korea, with its high literacy rate, could
benefit from exchanges to promote communication technology, improve
transportation, sustainable mineral development, and address good governance
issues.
In turn, we Canadians have a lot to learn. We cannot assume this is a one
way street. Exchanges create opportunities for us to see what it has been
like for Koreans to live in fear of attack -- real and imagined -- from
neighbors near and far away. When you talk with someone with a pencil or
textbook or computer in hand, and the one you are talking to has a book and
a calculator in his hand, there is less chance that you are going to be
shooting at each other. Academic exchanges are Canada's greatest need at the
moment as a way to facilitate understanding with the DPR of Korea. We could
be a leader.
Jake Buhler, Saskatoon, SK, Canada
*************************************************
WHAT NOW?
How many people in North Korea have unfettered access to information about
the world outside the DPRK?
(Jeff Nankivell, CIDA, Ottawa & Charles Burton, Brock University, St.
Catherines, Ontario, Canada)
[Answers should be e-mailed to: editor at CanKor.ca]
*************************************************
End CanKor # 245
*************************************************
CanKor is an electronic information service for readers interested in the
issues of peace and security on the Korean peninsula, published by
Weingartner Consulting. Financial support is received from the Canadian
International Development Agency (CIDA). Views expressed on the CanKor
website or weekly digest are those of the respective authors, and do not
necessarily reflect the official policies or positions of CanKor, CIDA or
Weingartner Consulting. CanKor accepts no liability for inaccuracies, errors
or omissions. Copyright of all items listed or reprinted rests with the
original publishers. CanKor provides links to originals when available. To
subscribe or unsubscribe, and for all other communication, please address
the CanKor editorial team by e-mail at editor at CanKor.ca. Editor: Erich
Weingartner; Managing Editor: Miranda Weingartner; Research: Marion Current,
Ilene Solomon, Danielle Goldfinger; Web developer: David Seguin. Please
visit our website at: www.CanKor.ca
*************************************************
More information about the CanKor
mailing list